College Students Value Free Expression In the Abstract, But Not When Pressed For Details
03-12-2018 10:25am

College Students Value Free Expression In the Abstract, But Not When Pressed For Details

A new poll from Gallup and the Knight Foundation, supported by the American Council on Education, the Charles Koch Foundation, and the Stanton Foundation, shows that college students’ views on the First Amendment and free speech are nuanced and complicated.

College students support free speech—at least in the abstract—according to a new poll from Gallup and the Knight Foundation. The poll, an annual measurement of college students’ perception of and support for freedom of speech, shows that the vast majority, 90 percent, think that using violence to prevent someone from speaking is never acceptable. And while this figure leaves ten percent of students who think violence is acceptable “sometimes,” but the findings are inconsistent with stereotypes of college students as ill-informed free speech denouncers.

Overwhelmingly, students agree that protecting citizens’ free speech rights is important to a democracy, though they also equally agree that promoting an inclusive society that is welcoming of diverse groups is also important to a democracy. When asked to select which of these is more important, students select promoting an inclusive society, without understanding that free speech is necessary for creating an inclusive community wherein all people can voice their opinions, protest injustices, and work towards a better society.

Students’ perceptions of the security of a free press have also dropped dramatically since last year: In 2016, 81 percent of students said that they believe freedom of the press was secure; during the 2017 poll 60 percent of students said the same. This dramatic decrease isn’t without basis—Cato Institute polling found that 63 percent of Republicans say journalists are “an enemy of the people.”

The manifold attacks that the media faces on a regular basis—especially legal threats and obstruction—threaten to erode the right of a free press. Groups like the American Society of News Editors can help protect more journalists as they pursue the stories that hold governments and institutions accountable.

Furthermore, discussions about controversial issues have expanded outside the classroom. Students surveyed said that most of these discussions take place on social media instead of in public areas on campus.

As students increasingly use social media to express themselves and debate social and political issues, maintaining free platforms for civil debate will be critical to fostering a society that appreciates and exercises its free speech rights. Scholars like those at the Knight First Amendment Institute at Columbia will continue to have a large role in understanding how social and digital media can expand our free speech rights and be kept free from government surveillance and censorship.

Overall, while college students may see the importance of free speech and the First Amendment when it comes to maintaining a free press, their appreciation of how free speech can help them create a more inclusive society could be expanded through more education. Perhaps they’re in the right environment for it.

The Charles Koch Foundation supports scholars working on free speech and toleration issues.

Learn More

Other Supported Research On Free Speech

UCLA Professor John Villasenor Finds College Students’ Hostility Towards Free Speech

Learn More

Who You Gonna Call? ASNE

The American Society of News Editors hotline is at the forefront of protecting reporters’ rights. A grant from the Charles Koch Foundation supports ASNE's legal hotline.

Learn More

The Knight First Amendment Institute Provides Critical Scholarship On Digital Free Speech

Learn More

Sign up for updates